As an Amazon Associate Lucky Belly earn from qualifying purchases.
Lucky Belly » Top 5 Best Toothpaste for Coffee Stains of 2022 – Whitening Fast!

Top 5 Best Toothpaste for Coffee Stains of 2022 – Whitening Fast!

best toothpaste for coffee stains
Image: Lucky Belly

Medical professionals call it “tooth discoloration.”

Coffee lovers call it “coffee stained teeth,” and we sure do not like it!

If you are looking for the best toothpaste for coffee stains, read these reviews and pick your match before you pour your next cup of joe.

What are coffee stains on teeth?

best baking soda toothpaste
Image: Lucky Belly

According to clinicians, coffee is one of the major causes for teeth staining in cases related to this condition.

The reason is simple: coffee is such a sought-after drink that it is consumed more frequently than any other.

The problem is that, over time, this precious dark liquid penetrates the tooth’s enamel, thus creating those annoying shades of brown that make our teeth look yellow.

Sadly, the more you drink, the more you are prone to stains (1).

While our teeth are protected by a smooth layer of enamel, this layer is not as smooth as it looks. All enamel suffers “wear and tear” throughout life.

This means that, the more we expose our enamel to food, drink, and tooth-cleaning products, the more prone it becomes to cracking into microscopic filaments.

These filaments leave tiny holes that are not visible to the naked eye. Nevertheless, these are the cracks in the pavement that allow coffee to penetrate the enamel and stain the tooth.

In the top of this, coffee is usually consumed either warm or cold. This intensifies the porosity under the enamel, making it more prone to minor cracks.

This porous substance beneath the enamel layer is called “dentin” and it is the area that holds most of the nerve endings that tingle in our teeth when we feel sensitivity to textures, sounds, and other triggers.

In conclusion, the brown stains in your teeth are a result of constant exposure to a dark liquid that filtrates through microscopic holes and cracks in your enamel.

Once the stains happen, it is very hard to remove them. Consuming coffee in moderation, and caring for your teeth after drinking it, are the best solutions to treat coffee stains in teeth.

Types of toothpaste for stained teeth

whitening toothpaste
Image: Lucky Belly

Fortunately, new toothpaste formulas are now FDA approved and out in the market for those who are looking for the best toothpaste for coffee stains.

According to this research, the three basic components for a toothpaste to fight stains include:

  • Baking soda – a natural exfoliator, it helps to mildly “scrape off” the delicate lining of your enamel that is immediately stained by coffee
  • Fluoride – this amazing element fortifies the enamel right after the baking soda has done its job. Strengthening the enamel is essential for other activities, such as brushing your teeth, eating, and drinking
  • Peroxide – this natural whitening can be found naturally in some forms of baking soda

Different brands will offer alternative or additional ingredients in their formulas.

Some formulas target fresh breath, while others focus on strengthening tooth enamel.

Ultimately, just select a toothpaste that meets your particular needs.

You can select from the following types of whitening toothpaste that target stains:

  • Whitening toothpaste for sensitive teeth – these toothpastes usually offer “gentle” whitening options since their purpose is to strengthen the tooth enamel by adding extra fluoride to the formula.
  • 3D, Optic White, and “Hollywood White” toothpaste– these popular pastes all feature baking soda peroxide as their whitening element. Some formulas feature extra baking soda for a stronger brush that can shed stains away. These kinds of toothpaste cater mainly to people with strong teeth that are easier to whiten because the enamel is not yet wearing out.
  • Whitening formulas with fresh breath options – your breath is part of your entire smile. Toothpaste manufacturers know this, so they offer the complete “package” for your teeth: whitening, strengthening, and refreshing.
  • Activated charcoal toothpaste with Xylitol, & Lactobacillus paracasei – Xylitol is a natural sweetener that also doubles as a cleanser. L.paracasei is a natural probiotic that allows good bacteria to grown in the mouth.

How to remove coffee stains from your teeth?

best toothpaste
Image: Lucky Belly

Brushing your teeth with the right toothpaste is the first step to a teeth-whitening routine. Other household remedies include:

  • Rubbing teeth with a dollop of baking soda – this practice consists of using a small rag and a drop or two of baking soda to rub the surface of every tooth. This is a good practice, but must be practiced in moderation, as you do not want to rub off too much enamel and make your teeth prone to infection.
  • Using activated charcoal – this is a newer trend which works, in principle, as the charcoal does bind to the tooth enamel and helps to remove the stains on the spot. Using the correct type of charcoal, users apply it on their teeth for 3-4 minutes and then rinse it out. While this is a great solution for stained teeth, it does not work with discolored teeth. It is a stain-only solution.


The best toothpaste for coffee stains 2022

1. Arm and Hammer Advance White Baking Soda Toothpaste in Frosted Mint

ARM & HAMMER Advance White Baking Soda Toothpaste, Winter Mint 6 oz (Pack of 6)

See On Amazon

It provides fluoride protection, no-peroxide whitening, and a fresh finish. The texture of the toothpaste features a strong baking soda content for a “deep clean” experience.

A strong, mint deodorizer naturally laces into the toothpaste to create a strong “after the dentist” feeling in your mouth.

It is a good combination of strong cleansing, enamel protection, and an agreeable mint aftertaste for freshness.


  • No peroxide whitening
  • Deep clean feeling
  • Baking soda is known to be a natural whitener
  • Strong mint scent for fresh breath
  • “After the Dentist” clean feeling
  • Rich in fluoride to strengthen tooth enamel


  • Focuses more on cleansing than whitening
  • No “gel” version available
  • This toothpaste version is harder to find in stores, and sometimes online is the best way to get it.


2. Colgate Total (Our Top Recommended)

Colgate Total Whitening Gel Toothpaste - 7.8 Ounce (Pack of 6)

See On Amazon

Colgate Total is a whitening toothpaste that also helps to prevent stains from happening with a 12-hour window of germ protection.

It fights cavities and plaque as well as gingivitis.

The whitening elements are said to coat teeth and protect them from stain while strengthening the tooth.

As the box indicates, it is “complete” oral care, meaning that it works with the tooth from all angles.


  • Preventative care
  • 12- hour protection
  • Complete tooth care
  • Freshens breath
  • Fights gingivitis, plaque
  • Prevents both stains and plaque


  • It is not entirely intended to whiten teeth
  • Maybe less powerful whitening teeth than competitive toothpaste
  • No gel version


3. Colgate Sensitive Toothpaste, Complete Protection, Mint

Colgate Sensitive Toothpaste, Complete Protection, Mint - 6 ounce (Pack of 3)

See On Amazon

Made for people with sensitive teeth and gums, this toothpaste has a formula for sensitivity relief that the company ascertains is clinically proven for 24/7 protection.

It is designed to fight tartar and remove plaque.

Its effects increase with usage, so it is recommended that you brush twice a day to obtain the best benefits of fresh breath, healthy gums, and cavity protection.

This is true of most toothpaste, though. You could not get the best results unless you really use the product.


  • Whitens teeth
  • Made for sensitive teeth and gums
  • Helps strengthen tooth enamels
  • Promotes healthy gums
  • Offers cavity protection
  • Results work over time


  • Cannot expect immediate results; must brush twice daily
  • Made for tooth sensitivity, more so than for whitening


4. Cali White Activated Charcoal and Organic Coconut Oil for Teeth Whitening

Cali White Activated Charcoal & Organic Coconut Oil Teeth WHITENING Toothpaste, Made in USA, Best Natural Whitener, Vegan, Fluoride Free, Sulfate Free, Organic, Black Tooth Paste, Pacific Mint (4oz)

See On Amazon

This activated charcoal toothpaste is like a “boutique” version of the typical toothpaste, from packaging, to color, to texture, to ingredients.

It contains activated charcoal (black powder), laced with coconut oil and baking soda for the “deep clean” feeling.

It is good for people with sensitive skin because the whitener in this toothpaste is not meant for the “optical white” finish, but for a natural finish.

The company calls it “oral detox.” The ingredients are the traditional ones needed for an everyday toothpaste, from texture, to smoothness, to flavor.


  • Made in the USA
  • Vegan
  • Free of gluten, SLS, fluoride, peroxide, triclosan, or parabens
  • Naturally flavored
  • It is not the powdery version of the traditional activated charcoal, but an actual paste.


  • Remember that these pastes do make your mouth black during brushing.
  • May have an aftertaste, it depends on your reaction to the activated charcoal.


5. Crest 3D White

Crest 3D White Toothpaste Radiant Mint (3 Count of 4.1 oz Tubes), 12.3 oz Packaging May Vary

See On Amazon

This toothpaste by Crest removes stays by 80%. It offers surface and enamel protection that prevents future stains.

It also contains fluoride to strengthen teeth. It features a very strong mint flavor, called “radiant mint” and it protects against cavities. It focuses


  • Removes up to 80% of stains
  • Protects against future stains
  • Focuses on strengthening as well as whitening teeth
  • Protects and strengthen tooth enamel


  •  Smaller size than other kinds of toothpaste
  • Radiant Mint flavor is different than other Crest flavors, and some may not like it



After thorough consideration, the clear winner of this roundup is Colgate Total. The 12-hour window of protection is what makes the product go from good to great.

There is a way to see this product working, and the fact that it solves the stain issue, and prevents it, is of even more importance.

The product offers total tooth protection, from the inside out, that is, strengthening and whitening. I would feel more comfortable drinking coffee.

This toothpaste will strengthen the tooth enough to prevent enamel to chip and let coffee stains in.​

It will also help remove those stains that have been there already. This product will take care of the nuisances of the world’s favorite drink.

Leave a Comment