11 Tips to Make a Perfect Cup of Jamaican Coffee

Everyone has heard of Irish coffee, coffee livened up with a generous helping of Irish whiskey, but how about Jamaican coffee? For a true taste of the Caribbean, swap that whiskey out for rum – and if that sounds intriguing, here’s our recipe for how to make the perfect cup!

Make sure you brew great coffee from great ingredients

If you want the perfect cup of Jamaican coffee, you need to make sure the coffee itself is as good as possible. It’s no good just brewing a cup of instant and pouring in a dose of rum – for the best results, you need to use the best ingredients and to pay great attention to each step during brewing.

Here are the steps you need to follow for the best results:

1. Use top coffee

Use top coffee
Image: Lucky Belly

For great coffee, you need great ingredients, and the first of these is the coffee beans.

If you want a truly decadent cup of the finest Jamaican coffee, we recommend you use Jamaican Blue Mountain beans since these are the best the island produces – and indeed are some of the most sought-after beans anywhere in the world.

If you are using Jamaican Blue Mountain, make sure they are genuine and that the bag carries the 100% Blue Mountain seal – Blue Mountain “blends” may contain less than 10% of the real thing and are a far inferior product.

Of course, some purists might consider using Blue Mountain beans to mix with rum to be a crime – if you don’t want to use Blue Mountain, substitute for any other high-quality beans (preferably of Jamaican origin).

2. Don’t forget the water!

Don’t forget the water!
Image: Lucky Belly

The second ingredient in coffee is water, but this is often overlooked. The coffee you brew is only as good as the ingredients you use, and if you use poor-quality water, the taste will suffer. For the very best results, always brew using purified water or spring water. Tap water is not good enough.

3. Choose your brewing method

Choose your brewing method
Image: Lucky Belly

Choose the brewing method you prefer. While French press or electric drip machines are fine, we recommend using the pour-over method for best results, especially if you are using real Jamaican Blue Mountain.

4. Make sure your beans are in perfect condition

Make sure your beans are in perfect condition
Image: Lucky Belly

Coffee beans are at their best between about a week and two weeks after roasting. Make sure your beans are fresh and that you store them properly.

Moisture, air, sunlight, and heat are the enemies of coffee, so store your beans in a cool, dry, dark place in an airtight container. Only bring them out when you are ready to grind them.

5. Grind the beans just before brewing

Grind the beans just before brewing
Image: Lucky Belly

Even the freshest coffee beans begin to deteriorate very quickly after grinding – within around as little as a minute, in fact. This is why you should grind your beans just before brewing and not in advance. Above all, make sure you are grinding them yourself and don’t opt for pre-ground.

6. Choose the right grind for your method

Choose the right grind for your method
Image: Lucky Belly

You should know the correct grind for the brewing method you are using. For a French press, you need a coarser grind, but for pour-over, you need a medium grind. If you don’t use the correct grind, your coffee will be over- or under-extracted, negatively impacting on the flavor.

7. Dose correctly

Dose correctly
Image: Lucky Belly

It is very important to use the right amount of coffee beans for the volume of coffee you plan to brew. This depends to a certain extent on your own personal preference – whether you like your coffee stronger or lighter – but you there are certain limits.

In general, a good place to start is two tablespoons of coffee beans for each 8oz of coffee you want to make. Feel free to take this as a starting point from which to experiment – the real golden rule of brewing coffee is that the perfect cup is the one you like most.

8. Heat the water to the correct temperature

Heat the water to the correct temperature
Image: Lucky Belly

Water that is too hot will scald the coffee, making it bitter, but the water that is not hot enough will not extract the coffee properly. The ideal temperature is 196-204°F. It is best to use a thermometer, but if you don’t have one, boil the water and then leave it to stand for one minute before using.

9. Use a gooseneck kettle

Use a gooseneck kettle
Image: Lucky Belly

If you are using the pour-over method, you should make sure you use a gooseneck kettle. This will allow you to pour the water onto the grounds slowly and accurately to ensure perfectly even extraction.

If you prefer a richer, more intense coffee, you should pour more slowly; for a lighter taste, pour a little faster. Since you are going to add rum to this coffee, we recommend pouring more slowly for a more robust flavor that can stand up to the strength of the rum.

You may find that if your coffee is too light, the flavor of the rum will overpower it.

10. Add the Jamaican rum of your choice

Add the Jamaican rum of your choice
Image: Lucky Belly

Up until this point, we have focused on the brewing part. Without a great coffee, you can’t make great Jamaican coffee – but now we need to add the rum.

As we said before, you can’t just throw in any old ingredients and expect a great result, so make sure you select a good quality Jamaican rum. It doesn’t matter which brand you use, as long as it is a decent rum. Use whichever rum you prefer – but the better the rum, the better the result.

Add a dose of rum to each cup. The amount is up to you, but about 1oz is a good place to start. If that’s too strong, start off with a little less.

11. Pour over the cream and serve

Pour over the cream and serve
Image: Lucky Belly

For the finishing touch, take a teaspoon and slowly pour cream over the back of the spoon and onto the coffee so that it floats on top. Once this is accomplished, your delicious Jamaican coffee is ready to serve.

Feel free to sweeten with brown sugar, demerara sugar as required.

The delicious taste of the Caribbean

Jamaican coffee makes a delicious and exotic alternative to Irish coffee – whether you’re in the Caribbean or somewhere else far away just dreaming of palm trees and white sand beaches. But wherever you are, now you know how to make the perfect cup of Jamaican coffee!

2 thoughts on “11 Tips to Make a Perfect Cup of Jamaican Coffee”

Leave a Comment