Before you rush to replace your Keurig, check out these common Keurig mistakes and try those quick tips to correct them. But if your reasons for replacing your Keurig are less practical and more ethical, you still have lots of options. These range from DIY lattes to rival brands.
But how can you be sure you’ve bought the best Keurig alternative? Well, we’ll start by reviewing seven popular replacements for your Keurig. Then, we’ll explore a few buying tips for your shopping trip. Lastly, we’ll recommend the Keurig alternative we think you should buy. Let’s go!
Table of Contents
Quick Glance: The Best Keurig Alternatives on the Market
When Keurigs first hit the market, a lot of us we wowed by their speed, style, and convenience. But some of us still worry about K-cups and their effect on the environment.
So you might be determined to replace your Keurig despite its many alternate uses (it’s just boiling water). Let’s look at some of the top factors and features to look out for as you scout Keurig alternatives.
Keurigs were invented to bring the gourmet café taste into your home. So if you want to buy a Keurig alternative, you need a brand and model that brews your favorite type of coffee.
Many coffee makers are restricted to either espresso or drip coffee. But if you but a dual brew coffee maker, you can have both. You could also get a coffee maker with a steamer and a frother.
Initially, all pods were Keurig K-cups, and some coffee makers would only accept original –cups. But over time, K-cup clones came up and offered a wider variety.
So buy a Keurig alternative that works with pods from various brands, including Keurig. Some coffee makers will accept different pod sizes. And some K-cup clones can brew tea, hot chocolate, or even instant soup.
Look for a Keurig alternative that has an adapter. This lets it hold K-cup 1.0s, K-cup 2.0s, K-cup clones, and even coffee grounds. But beyond the size ad style of your coffee pod, consider cup size ad carafe size.
If your Keurig alternative is a dual brewer, look for a model that serves 10 to 12 cups with a carafe that’s marked. For a single-serve device, focus on cup size.
Some Keurig alternatives will let you push a button or turn a dial to verify the number of cups. It will then feed the correct amount of water through your coffee maker.
Some devices take it even a step further, allowing you to brew 6-ounce, 8-ounce, or 10-ounce cups with a single touch. The wrong cup size can easily … water down your coffee, pun intended. So buy an automated model.
Some features that are popular among Keurig lovers are auto shut-on, auto shut-off, scheduled brewing, iced coffee features, and removable drip trays.
So you’re the best Keurig alternative should have these functions as a bare minimum. Plus, if you’re still into Keurig, your replacement must be compatible with original K-cups variants. Get a large reservoir too.
Brewing time matters as well. Some Keurig alternatives will prepare your coffee in less than five minutes and require minimal clean-up. Some brands can brew as fast as 30 seconds, but do a state test first – you may not like the taste of instant K-cup coffee.
Consider a model with a ‘strong’ or ‘bold’ button. It slows the drip rate, making your coffee more concentrated.
The Best Keurig Alternative on the Market 2021
1. Breville Nespresso Virtuo
The Keurig alternative you buy will largely depend on your pain points. What do you (dis)like about Keurig and what brand best fits your needs? Is your issue flavor, brewing speed, cost, or eco-friendliness? In all those cases, the Breville Nespresso is a smart selection. It has a 40-oz water reservoir and a unique silhouette they describe as ‘retro-modern’. It comes in matte black.
This system is super simple. It just needs one touch to brew, and it automatically stashes and ejects the coffee capsule as needed. The water tank is removable for easy refilling, and when you want your cuppa joe, just flip the dial to lock, unlock, or brew. It does need 15 to 20 seconds of preheating time, so plan accordingly. This is one of the most user-friendly Keurig alternatives.
Just slot in your coffee capsule and your Nespresso will automatically set the right temperature, water level, brewing pressure, and duration. The Nespresso can brew in five sizes including 5-ounce Gran Lungo and a 14-ounce Alto. It does iced drinks too. To show off its versatility, your Nespresso ships with an introductory pack of 12 color-coded coffee capsule flavors.
This brand has close to thirty variants, so you’re unlikely to bore your taste buds. And if you’d like to experiment with broader varieties of coffee, you can shell out a little more and buy the model with an aeroccino accessory. This frother is perfect for foamy beverages and coffee art.
Your Nespresso can brew different cup and capsules sizes. It has an adjustable drip so you conveniently for your travel mug, coffee flask, or even a dainty coffee cup beneath the drip. To get the most flavor out of your coffee capsule, the Nespresso makes 7,000 rotations per minute. And it automatically ‘throws out’ the capsule when it’s spent so there’s no waste.
The Breville Nespresso has a unique look and a wide variety of features. You can buy it with or without a frother, but it’sonly compatible with Nespresso capsules. It won’t work with K-cups.
- It measures 10.75 inches by 14 inches by 14.5 inches.
- The Breville brews five different coffee sizes.
- It spins at 7000 rpm for perfectly foamy results.
- Lots of people forget to preheat so they don’t get optimal results. Plus, it only works with Nespresso Vertuo capsules, no other brand.
2. MixPresso Single-Serve
How quickly do you need your coffee fix? This is the best Keurig alternative for a quick cuppa. It takes 30 seconds to preheat and barely a minute to brew. All its models are two-toned and you can order it in dark (blue-ish), red, or white, all accented with gray or black. It weighs under 8lb.
This coffee maker measures 11 inches by 13.5 inches by 6 inches. Its adjustable drip tray can hold tumblers and flasks at 7.5 inches tall. It works with both 1.0 and 2.0 K-cup clones so you can still enjoy your favorite Keurig flavors. The removable water reservoir sits at the back of the coffee maker. It has a wide brim for easy no-spill refilling and is made of BPA-free plastic.
To conserve power and keep your utility bills manageable, the Mixpresso shuts off automatically after hours of idling. You can preset it to turn off (or on) at a specific time. Just remember to leave the 45-oz reservoir loaded if you want to find prepped coffee (as opposed to a burnt don kitchen!) You can also pre-program your Keurig alternative to brew coffee in five pre-set sizes.
Some K-cup alternatives have dual-brew functionality, but this one is a single-serve device. It brews coffee cups that can range in size from 4oz to 12oz. If you’re buying it as a gift, it comes in premium packaging that your loved one will appreciate. Don’t forget to throw in a starter pack of K-cups and coffee pods so they can figure what they like. After all, versatile palates are acquired.
And with a Keurig alternative this fine, you don’t want to restrict yourself to the same bland variant you’ve always used. It’s a convenient, stylish addition to your kitchen that will widen your gourmet coffee experience. It’s an Italian brand and we know they pretty much invented all the ‘ccinos’ so you can feel confident you’re getting good quality for your money.
The Mixpresso is a pretty Keurig alternative with a lot of style and class. It brews quickly and smoothly while conserving energy. And it’s compatible with various coffee pod brands.
- It comes in stylish color combinations that look great on your countertop.
- Mixpresso has QuickBrew and auto shut-off functionality.
- This 1200W coffee maker takes just 30 seconds to preheat.
- It doesn’t brew steaming coffee (the maximum temperature is about 125F).
3. Mueller Ultima
Not everybody brews in bulk. Sometimes, you just want a quick cup to start your day. Or something to nurse your nasty morning-after mood. The Mueller Ultima does both. It accepts K-cups and pods from multiple brands so it’s easy to get your favorite flavors. This is strictly a one-person coffeemaker though, so if you have a roommate or a spouse, you’re sure to fight.
The Ultima works especially well with Schaffhauser coffee pods. It’s a small coffee maker with a 10oz reservoir. But the drip tray is removable so it can comfortably hold 4-inch coffee mugs. It’s a simple, no-frills device so if you want fancy features and heavy brewing, this isn’t it. It has no on/off button. Instead, your press a single button to brew, and switches itself off once done.
If you’re worried this tiny titan won’t impress your loved one, you could garnish the gift with a K-cup tower. It’s glossy foil wrap and bright colors are sure to delight. And your loved one (or even yourself) can try out all those flavors. You might settle on a new signature taste for your preferred coffee fix. Of course, the upside of this coffee maker is its minimal footprint.
It stands at 13.5 inches by 10.1 inches by 6.7 inches and weighs less than 4 pounds. So you can easily store it in the cabinet, or even carry it to the office or work site. As long as you can access an electrical outlet, you’ll be enjoying your favorite brew in minutes. You don’t even have to calculate brew times or temps because the coffee maker automatically goes off at the end.
So if you’re looking for a cute, compact, low-fuss brewer, this is a good choice. But if you plan to enjoy coffee with friends, you may need a model with a larger capacity and more features.
- The re-usable filter accepts coffee grounds.
- The Mueller brews in three minutes flat.
- Brewing is easy – just touch the button.
- It’s a mini model and it can only brew one 10oz cup at a time.
4. Cuisinart SS-10 Premium
Cuisinart has made a name for itself in the kitchen appliance space. And this Keurig alternative is part of the reason why. It makes up to 10 coffee cups at a time and its reservoir is almost double the industry standard. It also has a sleek silver silhouette that works with any decorative them and looks amazing on your countertop. Which is good, because it’s too big to stash!
But if you really must put it away, its squarish shape lets it tuck neatly into a larger cabinet. The coffee maker measures 11.03 inches by 9.33 inches by 12.13 inches and weighs a little under 10 pounds. It has six buttons you can combine to access the seemingly endless features.
It can be tricky figuring out what button summons which function though, so this Cuisinart ships with an instruction booklet. You can also find lots of demo videos to walk you through. The reservoir is extra-large and has a stay-warm feature. Meaning your coffee brews faster because it’s not starting from cold. But it can inflate utility bills unnecessarily, so use it with care.
Once you figure out how to use it, your coffee maker lets you brew coffee to extremely detailed specifications. You can select cup size, brewing temperature, and brewing time. It’s ideal for control-freaks who want their coffee done just so. But if you’re more of a get-up-and-go type of person, this may seem like a lot of work and you might prefer to use a coffee maker with presets.
One of the reasons that make it rise above the Keurig is the ‘rinse’ function. This makes cleaning and maintenance way easier. Plus, it prevents flavor leeching if your household residents prefer different K-cup variants. Plus, you can use the ‘hot water’ button to prepare other dishes and snacks like noodles, instant soup, or hot chocolate. Set it to hot or extra hot.
The Cuisinart is a handy coffee maker that has all the features of a Keurig. It has a little compartment on the side to store your re-usable filter basket for brewing grounds.
- It has a massive 72oz reservoir.
- The large LCD screen makes it easier to brew.
- The 32-inch power cord offers flexible countertop positioning.
- It has lots of features, which is nice, but it’s a bit of a waste since most coffee drinkers only end up using one or two.
5. Hamilton Beach Scoop Single-Serve (Our Top Pick)
If you’re replacing your Keurig to go green, this is the best Keurig alternative. How so? It only uses coffee grounds, so no foil covers, no plastic cups, no filter paper, no waste. Instead, grind coffee beans of your choice and put them in the permanent filter basket.
This mesh cup functions like a K-cup would, and offers the same level of convenience. Its smallest cup size (8 ounces) takes one-and-a-half minutes to brew. It’s largest (14 ounces) takes two-and-a-half. And because its housing is made of stainless steel, it’s durable, hardy, and low-maintenance. Its functions are basic though – the button toggles from decaf to regular.
In some ways, this is a more curated filter, because you can craft your own gourmet brew. But it’s also a lot more work calibrating the perfect brew. The scoop size is measured to brew single-serve cups, so it’s as effective as a K-cup. If you opt for regular brew, this Keurig alternative sets automatic drip rates. For bold coffee, the drip rate slows to give you a stronger beverage.
With all this automation, you may worry about accidental fires in the kitchen. Hamilton has a special safety feature to prevent that from happening. If you try to brew while the reservoir is empty, it won’t work. So you don’t have to worry about overheating or short-circuiting. That said, your Hamilton is somewhat prone to spills and overfilling. That’s usually user error though.
If you look at your filter scoop, it has a level marker. Fill your grounds to the lowest level, and grind them to a medium texture rather than a fine one. If the grounds are too high or too tiny, your Keurig alternative is more likely to overflow and cause a mess. But on the occasions when your coffee maker does spill, your drip tray is spill-proof so it won’t stick or stain.
Hamilton is one of the best alternatives to a Keurig because it eliminates K-cups completely. It’s a simple one-touch coffee machine that lets you brew in record time and shuts itself off after.
- It has a filter that serves as a coffee scoop.
- The stainless steel housing is easier to maintain.
- It doesn’t brew while empty so it won’t cause electrical flare-ups.
- You may not see this as a con since you’re looking for a Keurig alternative … but if you’re attached to your K-cups, it may upset that this Hamilton can only do coffee grounds.
6. Sboly Single Serve
Single-serve coffee brewers offer speed and convenience. But while they’re fine for black coffee, adding milk or cream might make your drink drab and tepid. You won’t face that challenge with the Sboly. It retains brewing temperatures to deliver a steaming mug every time. It’s a super-fast coffee maker that brews in 3 minutes without compromising strength or flavor.
This coffee maker measures 5.4 inches by 7.3 inches by 11.6 inches. It weighs 2.53 pounds so it’s quite portable, whether you’re storing it in a cabinet or carrying it to work. The coffee maker has two filter baskets – one for K-cups and one for coffee grounds. It’s a simple device with two buttons –one for grounds and one for capsules. The icons on the buttons show their function.
The water reservoir has clear markings so you can brew a cup that’s anywhere from 6 ounces to 14 ounces. The Keurig alternative is fitted with a hybrid needle that can puncture various brands of K-cups and capsules. To initiate the gadget’s self-cleaning sequence, press both buttons simultaneously. You should do this on alternate months unless you’re a heavy coffee user.
Sboly is on the smaller side though, both size-wise and capacity-wise. Its water reservoir only holds 14 ounces. The drip tray is removable so it’s easy to clean. Removing this tray also creates room for larger cups and mugs. The water reservoir has an inverse staircase design that helps you measure the right amount of water for your coffee cup size – 6 ounces to 14 ounces.
This coffee maker is simple and compact with two coffee adaptors and two buttons. It can brew over 200 cups of coffee before you need to engage the self-cleaning functionality.
- It has a self-cleaning feature.
- At under 3 pounds, it’s remarkably lightweight.
- This Sboly has dual-brew functionality.
- This brand doesn’t offer custom-sized water filters and the water reservoir only holds 16 ounces.
7. Black + Decker Single Serve
When you have limited storage space, you need a gadget that’s compact and convenient. Black + Decker checks both criteria. It has rounded edges that tuck into tight cabinets and countertop corners. The coffee maker measures 9.25 inches by 11.25 inches by 13 inches.
This snazzy plastic Keurig alternative brews 16 ounces of coffee directly into the travel mug it ships with. The travel mug has a lid to prevent spills. It fits snug under the coffee nozzle. This cute coffee maker doesn’t need much maintenance. It has a re-usable, removable filter that’s dishwasher-safe. It one of the most basic Keurig alternatives with just one button.
The appliance has a preset temperature that’s ideal for your chosen brew. And as soon as your coffee is ready, the coffee maker automatically cuts the power to conserve energy. The drip plate has a non-stick film so you don’t have to worry about coffee stains. It also has a cord storage slot. Press the button on the side to retract the cord. The coffee maker has a 2-year warranty.
Black + Decker is known for versatility and this two-way coffee maker can work with both K-cups and loose grounds. The red indicator light lets you know your device is ready to brew.
- Its boxy shape offers more convenient storage options.
- With just one button, it’s easy to operate.
- The brew basket can be cleaned in the dishwasher.
- The coffee brewed on this device is often weak.
Drip Drip Sip
Based on our research, we recommend the Hamilton Beach Scoop Single-Serve. Here’s why:
- It’s made of stainless steel.
- You can switch from regular strength to bold by touching a button.
- It takes 90 seconds to 2.5 minutes per brew depending on size.
- The scoop filter customizes your grounds.
- It doubles as a measuring cup and a filter basket.
- Cup size ranges from 8 to 14 ounces.
- The safety feature prevents brewing when the water reservoir is empty.
- It doesn’t use K-cups so it’s safer for the environment.
What Keurig alternative are you using at the moment? Show us a photo in the comments!